CLARITY Act: The Crypto Market Moves Ahead

17

After the CLARITY Act suffered a setback in the U.S. Senate, regulators are accelerating exemptions and consultations. The law is still not in place. What is the market doing in the meantime?

Following the failure of the CLARITY Act in the Senate, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) are shaping U.S. crypto rules one regulatory filing at a time. The industry is moving forward, but one question remains: how long will those rules last?

On September 15, the U.S. Senate failed to secure the 60 votes needed to open debate on the CLARITY Act, the bill intended to establish a regulatory framework for the digital asset market. Opposition reached 41 votes, and the bill, which had already passed the House of Representatives, remained on the Senate calendar with the November elections looming. Bitcoin fell below USD 76,000 following the vote.

What happened next unfolded quickly.

On September 17, the SEC granted a five-year exemption for on-chain trading of certain tokenized stocks, subject to volume limits. On October 1, it proposed rules allowing investment advisers and regulated funds to custody crypto assets, either through state-chartered trust companies or, under certain conditions, through self-custody. On October 5, the CFTC opened a consultation on a federal framework for leveraged retail trading, introducing a new category of crypto asset markets. The heads of both agencies had previously indicated that they would move forward with or without legislation.

Follow our channel: Frecuencia Money TV

 

 

What each agency can accomplish

The SEC is operating in its strongest domain: determining when the sale of a token constitutes a securities offering. Its Regulation Crypto Assets proposal, introduced in August and open for public comment through October 20, provides for a USD 5 million startup exemption and fundraising exemptions of up to USD 20 million or USD 75 million per year.

The CFTC, by contrast, faces a limitation: it cannot grant itself authority over spot markets through regulation alone, which was the bill’s central promise. Its proposal is limited to the leveraged segment, and the agency itself acknowledges that it cannot require crypto transactions to take place on platforms registered with it without an act of Congress.

The market’s response

Some industry participants see a short-term advantage. Matt Hougan of Bitwise argues that direct regulatory action may be more effective than waiting for legislation and its subsequent rulemaking, a process that could take years. Paul McCaffrey of KBW notes that greater clarity is driving mergers and acquisitions across crypto, traditional finance, and fintech. Binance, meanwhile, is urging industry participants to engage in the consultation processes to ensure that the rules are technologically neutral and suitable for markets that operate around the clock.

Others point to the regulatory gap. Jonathan Jachym, head of policy at Payward, Kraken’s parent company, stressed that a comprehensive framework is still missing, despite bipartisan recognition of the need for one. Hougan also warns that the delay could preserve barriers to entry that favor established exchanges such as Coinbase and Kraken.

The risk of regulatory durability

The weak point is permanence. Agency rules are easier to reverse than legislation: a future administration or a court can change them, a risk that has increased since the Supreme Court’s 2024 Loper Bright decision ended judicial deference to agencies’ interpretations of ambiguous statutes. Legal experts agree that a comprehensive federal framework for spot trading is still lacking.

That is why public comment proceedings are becoming central to the debate: rules adopted through a formal consultation process are harder to undo once products have been built around them. Some law firms estimate that the CFTC will not have final rules in place before late 2027.

What Latin America should watch

For Latin American exchanges and fintechs operating in the United States or planning to tokenize assets, the current landscape offers greater clarity, but only on a provisional basis. The key date is October 20, when the SEC’s public comment period closes, followed by the CFTC’s 60-day comment period.

 

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here